Kelly
Who is that in the picture?
Unknown
Feigning ignorance is technically lying…
Kelly
Why are you showing me this picture?
Unknown
Let’s talk about how you knew that girl instead.
Kelly
The girl in the photograph?
Unknown
And the last time you saw her was on Halloween night two years ago.
Kelly
How did you know that?
Kelly
And why do you care about some woman in a picture?
Unknown
Now I want you to say her name.
Unknown
I won’t ask again.
Kelly
That’s a picture of Violet.
Unknown
Good girl. Doesn’t it feel better to stop pretending you have no idea who she is?
Kelly
Of course I know who she is.
Kelly
I never said I didn’t.
Unknown
You got me on a technicality.
Kelly
Look, I’m not her, if that’s what you’re thinking.
Kelly
I’m not Violet in the witness protection program or something.
Kelly
Are you some kind of stalker trying to track her down?
Kelly
Because if so, I don’t know where she is.
Kelly
We can call it a night right now.
Unknown
You don’t know where she is?
Kelly
I don’t! And I’m not her, if that’s your game.
Kelly
You think I’m Violet and moved and changed my name to Kelly.
Kelly
And you’re trying to make me admit I’m her.
Kelly
You’re wrong. I’M NOT HER.
Unknown
Oh, this isn’t a case of mistaken identity.
Unknown
I know you’re not Violet.
Kelly
Screw you! I’m done with this!
Unknown
I think I preferred it when you were flirting with me.
Unknown
MAYBE THAT WAS YOUR MISTAKE
Unknown
Elaborate on how you knew Violet.
Kelly
We went to school together. College.
Unknown
Go on. You went to college with Violet.
Unknown
You’re terrible at storytelling. DETAILS!
Kelly
We went to school together back East.
Kelly
A couple years ago. I graduated and moved away.
Kelly
What? That’s the truth.
Kelly
I thought you wanted the truth, not stories?
Unknown
I like TRUE stories. Even on Halloween.
Unknown
Especially on Halloween.
Unknown
You went to college with her…until she went MISSING.
Unknown
And we both know she was more to you than some chick you went to school with.
Kelly
A lot of people knew her. She was popular.
Unknown
You’re deflecting. Stop pretending you don’t know her.
Unknown
There will be consequences if you continue to lie.
Kelly
I’m calling the police!
Unknown
You wouldn’t be that stupid.
Kelly
You…why does it matter if I knew her? Who is she to you?
Unknown
Ah, that’s two questions. I’ll answer the first.
Kelly
What does that even mean?
Unknown
Nope. My turn. How well did you know Violet?
Unknown
You don’t sleep in a tiny room with someone for a year without getting close.
Unknown
How good of friends would you say you were?
Kelly
We were…I wanted to be her best friend.
Unknown
Interesting that you’d say that.
Unknown
When did you first realize that you wanted Violet to be your bestie?
Kelly
I don’t know. We just started talking.
Unknown
No, there was ONE night that changed things.
Unknown
October 31, when someone dumped you.
Kelly
Jarod. She dried my tears, we dressed up and went out.
Kelly
To a costume party Violet knew about.
Kelly
And we danced. And drank.
Kelly
How do you know this?
Unknown
I told you. I know everything.
Unknown
And no, this isn’t Jarod.
Unknown
Say thank you. I gave you that for free.
Unknown
Would you say your relationship was defined by that night?
Unknown
With her taking care of you, drawing you into her circle of friends?
Unknown
Having you tag along?
Kelly
I suppose so, yes. Until that night, she’d never really had time for me.
Unknown
And that made you angry.
Kelly
I didn’t like it when she ignored me, but whatever.
Unknown
You were jealous of her.
Kelly
Yes. Everyone loved her.
Unknown
Did you come to care for her?
Unknown
Or were you just pretending you liked her
Kelly
Yes. Yes I CARED, I never pretended about that!
Unknown
You seemed to care about a lot of people that night.
Unknown
Especially the guys.
Kelly
It was a party on Halloween!
Kelly
I was being friendly.
Unknown
You dressed as a cat and wore a skimpy black top.
Unknown
And a sexy white wig.
Unknown
All the guys’ eyes were on you.
Unknown
And you loved it.
Unknown
That’s what you’re supposed to be figuring out.
Unknown
Before I lose my patience.
Kelly
I’m calling the police.
Unknown
If you called them, I’d…
Unknown
Actually, go ahead.
Unknown
Call the police. I’m sure they’d love to hear your confession.
Kelly
I didn’t do anything!
Kelly
You’ve got me confused with someone else.
Unknown
That’s another lie.
Unknown
Have you ever seen a dead body?
Unknown
I’ll bet you have.
Unknown
Recognize this photograph?
Unknown
I’ll give you a hint…
Unknown
It was taken the night Violet went missing.
Kelly
How did you get this picture?
Unknown
If you contact anyone else in any way
Unknown
I will tell EVERYONE what you did.
Unknown
I’ll tell everyone
