Kelly
What are you going to do to me?!
Kelly
Please, I haven’t done anything to you!
Kelly
Please, I’ll do anything!
Unknown
And stop whimpering, I can hear you through the door.
Kelly’s trembling hand fumbles with the chain a few times before she can unlock the door and open it.
When she does, the porch is empty.
Unknown
Awww, do you miss me already?
Unknown
I can come back if you’d like.
Kelly
I don’t know how you found me, but please, I’m begging you to leave.
Kelly
I won’t even call the cops.
Unknown
Are you actually this stupid?
Unknown
My stomach hurts from laughing. I’m DYING!
Unknown
No wait, that was Violet.
Kelly
Just leave me alone!
Unknown
Look down. I left you a little Halloween present on the welcome mat.
Kelly
What’s in the plastic bag? Poison?
Unknown
Now you’re just being ridiculous.
Unknown
Not to mention rude.
Kelly
Rude?! You’re the one stalking me and making me play a stupid game and…
Unknown
I’ve given you a gift.
Unknown
It’s the perfect costume for you.
Unknown
Take it inside and open it.
Inside the bag is the same cat costume she wore two years ago in the photograph.
Stiff with Violet’s blood
Unknown
I even included the white wig!
Unknown
Although it’s mostly red now with all that blood.
Kelly
How did you get this?
Unknown
Oh good, you like it.
Unknown
I was so scared you wouldn’t.
Kelly
If you’re going to do something to me, just DO IT!
Kelly
Stop dragging it out!
Unknown
You’re not the one in charge tonight.
Unknown
Stop crying and PUT. IT. ON.
Unknown
Don’t make me ask again…
Kelly puts on the cat costume over her pajamas.
Kelly
I’m not! How long do I have to wear it?
Unknown
I don’t know yet. First things first.
Unknown
I want you to meow for me.
Unknown
We don’t want to limit our fun.
Kelly
This isn’t fun, you psychopath!
Unknown
How does it feel?
Unknown
Only, it looks like you’ve gained a little weight since that night.
Unknown
Stress eating, perhaps? Tsk tsk.
Unknown
I need more details than that.
Unknown
Paint me a picture or I’ll come and see it for myself.
Kelly
The fabric is stiff.
Unknown
From her blood. SAY IT.
Kelly
The fabric is still stiff from her blood.
Unknown
Blood YOU spilled.
Unknown
Clothes you threw in the trash behind your dorm.
Kelly
You couldn’t know this unless…
Kelly
You were there that night. You saw me throw them away.
Kelly
That’s how you know all this.
Unknown
Now you’re getting somewhere…
Kelly
Why didn’t you say something then?!
Unknown
My turn! How does it feel?
Unknown
Wearing those clothes again.
Kelly
I just answered that!
Unknown
No. That was about the clothes themselves.
Unknown
I want to know how it feels EMOTIONALLY to wear the clothes you killed Violet in.
Kelly
How the hell am I supposed to answer that?!
Unknown
Dig deep. Let’s get emotional.
Unknown
We’re in this together now.
Unknown
Do NOT make me ask again…
Unknown
I feel really…close to you right now.
Kelly
I feel sick even thinking about that night.
Unknown
You’re not trying to get a sympathy vote, are you?
Unknown
The idea of anyone feeling bad for YOU after what you’ve done…
Kelly
No! I feel awful for what happened.
Kelly
How the night started out so good and ended
Unknown
How? You know I like stories…
Kelly
We had an argument and she got out of the car.
Kelly
Said she’d rather walk home.
Unknown
Yes. And so you followed her and hit her with your car.
Kelly
My life ended that night too, you know.
Unknown
You got away with murder.
Kelly
You think I got away with ANYTHING?!
Kelly
I still have nightmares about the sound she made hitting the water.
Unknown
Good. I hope your conscience has tortured you for the things you did that night.
Kelly
I didn’t mean to! I only meant to scare her. I swear to god I only meant to scare her.
Kelly
I was going to rush at her. I don’t know, I just wanted for her to get back in the car so we could go home.
Kelly
I ONLY meant to rev the engine.
Kelly
But I’d had too much to drink and my foot slipped off the brake,
Kelly
And the car jerked forward so fast and I hit her.
Kelly
I stopped the car and got out.
Kelly
I saw her hanging half off the bridge.
Kelly
There was blood everywhere.
Kelly
I checked for her pulse and couldn’t feel anything.
Unknown
And then I panicked and pushed her off the bridge into the water.
Unknown
I know that part.
Unknown
I’m not interested in the WHAT.
Unknown
This isn’t a therapy session where we talk about you and your feelings.
Unknown
I want you to dive into how it would have felt for HER.
Unknown
Not physically. Emotionally.
Kelly
I don’t understand.
Unknown
How would Violet have felt to know that you hated her?
Unknown
You said it yourself, you were jealous of her.
Unknown
Everyone loved her.
Unknown
And you couldn’t handle that. So you killed her.
Kelly
Yeah, everyone loved her, but I loved her too!
Kelly
It was an accident!
Unknown
You “accidentally” covered up your crime, though...
Unknown
I’ve never seen that kind of sentiment on a Hallmark card.
Unknown
‘I love you so much I want to dump your body off a bridge.’
Unknown
Nope, can’t see that campaign catching on.
Kelly
This has gone on long enough.
She tears the cat costume off and stuffs it back into the bag.
Kelly
I don’t want to play this anymore.
Kelly
I’M NOT PLAYING YOUR TWISTED LITTLE GAME ANYMORE!
Unknown
Playing? You still think this was a game?
Unknown
This was never a game to me.
Unknown
And if you really think that, maybe you’re too stupid to live.
Unknown
The world would be better without you, Kelly.
Unknown
I’m pretty sure we both know that.
A heavy thumping comes from upstairs
Kelly
What is that? Is that you?!
Kelly
Are you in my house?!
Unknown
Maybe it’s the beating of your telltale heart…
The footsteps move towards the stairs.
